REVIEW / Toy Story: Retro Roundup! (PC)

There are few things more dangerous to a gamer’s wallet than hearing a familiar theme song and suddenly remembering the exact room where you played a game 25 years ago. The Toy Story: Retro Roundup! is basically Digital Eclipse opening an old toy chest, dumping everything onto the floor, and asking if you remember them. The collection brings together five movie-based adventures spanning the mid-1990s through the early 2000s, including Toy Story, Toy Story 2, Buzz Lightyear of Star Command, Toy Story Racer, and A Bug’s Life. It actually contains 11 versions of those games across console and handheld releases, which is a pretty substantial chunk of licensed-game history. The catch is that nostalgia can be a powerful filter, and some of these games absolutely benefit from it more than others.

The original Toy Story is where this whole retro trip begins, and it is fascinating to see just how much developers were trying to squeeze out of 16-bit hardware in 1995. Rather than simply giving players a basic run-and-jump platformer, the game attempts to recreate scenes and gimmicks from the movie while throwing in different styles of gameplay along the way. There are standard platforming sections, timed challenges, combat encounters, and even vehicle-based sequences, giving the adventure more variety than you might remember. This game had impressive rendered visuals and surprisingly ambitious design back then. However, Toy Story  had very uneven stages and some frustrating moments. Playing it today is definitely a time capsule, but it is one that still has enough personality to make you smile.

That personality is important because the first Toy Story is probably the most obvious example of a game that feels like it came straight out of the 1990s. Woody looks exactly like the kind of character developers were desperate to make recognizable on limited hardware, while the environments constantly remind you that this was once a major animated movie being transformed into an interactive experience. There is something wonderfully charming about seeing familiar movie moments recreated with chunky sprites and old-school animation. At the same time, the age shows through in the controls and level design, and modern players may wonder why some jumps seem determined to ruin their afternoon. Thankfully, Retro Roundup! adds modern quality-of-life options such as Rewind and Practice Mode, giving players a safety net that simply did not exist when these games originally hit store shelves.

From there, the collection jumps to Toy Story 2, and this is where things get noticeably more ambitious. The PlayStation, Nintendo 64, Dreamcast, and PC versions turned Buzz’s adventure into a larger 3D platforming experience with hub areas, collectibles, objectives, and multiple locations inspired by the movie. The game gave players more freedom than a simple linear platformer because objectives can be tackled at different points rather than forcing everything into one rigid path. That makes Toy Story 2 one of the collection’s strongest nostalgia plays because it feels like the moment licensed movie games started becoming genuinely fun games in their own right.

There is also a special charm to Toy Story 2 because it captures the late-1990s obsession with turning animated movies into sprawling 3D adventures. Andy’s house, Al’s Toy Barn, the airport, and other familiar locations become playgrounds rather than merely backdrops for cutscenes. You collect items for the other toys, complete missions, hunt around for secrets, and occasionally find yourself fighting with the camera more than the actual enemies. The movie connection remains strong thanks to recognizable characters, dialogue, music, and environments, although some versions sacrificed presentation features that made the PlayStation release particularly memorable. With Rewind available in the collection, some of those infamous platforming moments should be considerably less painful.

Then there is Buzz Lightyear of Star Command, which feels like someone grabbed the Buzz half of Toy Story and decided it needed its own Saturday morning cartoon adventure. The game moves away from Woody’s slower platforming style and puts Buzz into a more straightforward action-focused experience involving enemies, power-ups, vehicles, and boss encounters. While the game seems heavily aimed at younger players rather than experienced gamers with its simplicity, it iis also part of its nostalgic appeal because this is exactly the kind of licensed game that could occupy a kid’s weekend simply because Buzz Lightyear was on the box. It may not be the hidden masterpiece of the collection, but it has that wonderfully uncomplicated energy that makes it difficult to completely dislike.

Unfortunately, Buzz Lightyear of Star Command also shows why nostalgia needs a reality check. The basic structure of chasing criminals through relatively linear stages, shooting enemies, collecting coins, and buying upgrades can become repetitive surprisingly quickly. There are some neat ideas involving weapons, jetpacks, shields, hoverboards, and other equipment, but the experience rarely develops those ideas into anything particularly sophisticated. The colorful visuals and recognizable character designs do a lot of heavy lifting, and younger players were clearly the intended audience. For adults returning to it decades later, however, this one may be more enjoyable as a historical curiosity than as the collection’s star attraction.

Thankfully, Toy Story Racer brings something completely different to the party. Released in 2001, it takes the familiar characters and drops them into a kart-racing setup where Woody, Buzz, Bo Peep, RC, and others race around tracks inspired by the movies. The PlayStation version includes 19 levels and even throws in a destruction derby mode, which is a pretty fun way to make a licensed racing game feel slightly less like a bargain-bin racing game clone. The racing itself is fairly straightforward and its power-ups were not exactly genre-defining. Still, hearing those familiar characters compete while racing through oversized toy-themed environments has a wonderfully goofy early-2000s charm.

Toy Story Racer may actually benefit the most from the passage of time because it does not pretend to be anything more complicated than a fun little kart racer. It has familiar characters, unlockables, toy-based vehicles, recognizable locations, and enough modes to keep you poking around after the novelty wears off. It was never going to overthrow that big Nintendo racing game at the time, but that does not mean it lacks personality. There is something delightfully absurd about watching Woody race Buzz around a track while everyone is effectively driving toys that are already lying around Andy’s world. If your nostalgia leans toward the era when every popular animated property apparently needed its own kart racer, this is going to hit the sweet spot.

And then, because Digital Eclipse apparently decided one more Pixar surprise couldn’t hurt, there is A Bug’s Life. Technically, this is the odd toy in the box because it has nothing to do with Toy Story, but its inclusion makes perfect sense from a preservation standpoint. The 1998 platformer puts players in control of Flik and mixes 3D exploration with jumping, enemy attacks, collectibles, and environmental puzzles. 

The nostalgia surrounding A Bug’s Life is especially interesting because the movie itself is remembered more fondly than its game adaptation. Flik’s adventure has some genuinely clever mechanics involving seeds that grow into different plants, requiring players to figure out how to reach areas and collectibles. Unfortunately, the camera can be troublesome, the combat gets repetitive, and some of the technical limitations are painfully obvious today. 

What really elevates the Toy Story: Retro Roundup! above a simple collection of ROMs is everything Digital Eclipse has built around the games. The package includes a virtual museum filled with development materials, vintage photographs, design documents, and archival content, along with new interviews featuring people connected to the original productions. There is also a Music Player containing the soundtracks from the games, which is an extremely welcome addition for anyone who remembers these tunes from childhood. That preservation material gives the collection context instead of treating the games as disposable relics. For a franchise built around memories of childhood, having a museum dedicated to how those memories were created is almost as important as the games themselves.

The modern conveniences are another major win, particularly for anyone who does not have the patience of their 10-year-old self anymore. Rewind lets you back up after a bad jump, missed platform, or poorly timed attack, while Rex’s Cheat Codes can unlock things such as unlimited lives, invincibility, characters, or levels. Practice Mode and improved instructions also make the games easier to understand for newcomers who were not around when these titles were originally released. Some retro purists may argue that these options make the games too easy, but nobody is forcing you to use them. Honestly, after spending years watching Buzz fall off the same platform for the 47th time, I am perfectly happy to have a giant rewind button sitting there.

Ultimately, Disney/Pixar Toy Story: Retro Roundup! understands that its biggest selling point is not technological brilliance but memory. These are games from a time when getting a movie tie-in felt like getting an extension of the movie itself, and simply seeing Woody, Buzz, Flik, and the rest of the gang on a game box could make a kid ridiculously excited. Digital Eclipse has done the smart thing by preserving not only the games but also the history surrounding them, while adding enough modern conveniences to make revisiting them far less frustrating. Not every title has aged equally well, and some will definitely have you asking yourself how you ever managed without an analog stick, camera control, or rewind. But when the music kicks in, Woody starts running across Andy’s room, or Buzz launches into another ridiculous mission, that little blast of childhood nostalgia is still surprisingly powerful.

---

This review is based on a retail copy of the game provided by the publisher.